Instead, they can ask students to decide whether a group of words is a sentence or a fragment — not an easy distinction for many to grasp. Over the past two and a half years, we have examined programs at similar colleges and studied best practices nationwide. Why Graduate Students Can't Write: Implications of Research on Writing Anxiety for Graduate Education. That makes sense: When students put what they’ve read into their own words, they’re more likely to absorb and retain it. Also, there is life outside of the classroom. Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on. For example, a teacher can give students the beginning of a sentence based on a text and ask them to finish it using the conjunction “but,” requiring them to examine the text closely enough to find two contrasting ideas. When students have a basic grasp of sentences, then — and only then — should they move on to planning and drafting paragraphs. But if middle and high school students are writing poorly constructed sentences, they’ll almost certainly end up writing poorly constructed essays. Our Students Can't Write Very Well—It's No Mystery Why . (HOD). Share your thoughts », How COVID-19 Will Change Academic Parenting, Crafting a Post-Pandemic Strategy for Your College and University, Call to Action: Marketing and Communications in Higher Education, COVID-19 Info on Your Website: A Few Best Practices, Wellness and Mental Health in 2020 Online Learning. Once students understand the concept of a sentence, they can learn to use conjunctions such as “but” and “because.” Then they can create complex sentences — including those beginning with subordinating conjunctions such as “although” or “despite” — to introduce variety into their writing. “In grades six to eight, we must see extended writing — multiple cohesive paragraphs that clearly reflect strong organization and style,” the report’s authors lamented. In addition, we are proposing that we dispense with our standard second course in research writing, revise our English 101 into an introduction to academic writing, and institute a writing-across-the-curriculum program. At my university, I chair a faculty committee charged with reviewing and revising our general education curriculum. Our intention is to infuse the general education curriculum with additional writing practice and to prompt departments to take more responsibility for teaching the conventions of research and writing in their disciplines. Spread the loveWriting is a recursive skill. Laurence Musgrove is an associate professor of English and foreign languages at Saint Xavier University, in Chicago. Graduate schools can offer help by (1) establishing programs that incorporate thesis and dissertation research into the course work, (2) providing realistic but firm deadlines for the completion of courses and graduate degrees, (3) providing more information about research methodology and writing, (4) explaining the advantages and disadvantages of various organizational formats typical of papers in the student's discipline, (5) telling students what the faculty expects in breadth and depth of research investigation, (6) helping students to schedule their time and effort realistically, and (7) keeping the students accountable to their timetable. For example, the Education Trust recently studied more than 1,200 middle school writing assignments to see whether they aligned with the Common Core and faulted them in part because they didn’t require students to write at length. Lots of them. University students can't write decent English. Therefore, I propose that all institutions of higher learning adopt the following policy. A teacher confronted with an essay full of mechanical and conceptual errors may not know where to begin in correcting the essay. “When we try to do creative and journal writing,” she said, “students don’t have the tools to put their ideas on paper.” But let’s not just blame the students. The standards also assume students in middle and high school already know the rules of capitalization, punctuation and sentence construction. With the advent of e-mail, writing ability has become more important than ever, and writing deficiencies have become increasingly apparent. In other words, when push comes to shove, I’ve found that most students really do know how to write -- that is, if we can help them learn to value and care about what they are writing and then help them manage the time they need to compose effectively. The Common Core education standards, adopted by more than 40 states and the District, attempt to address this deficit. They require that students learn to write fluently about the meaning of what they’re learning — not just in English class, but also in history, science and maybe even math class. After twelve years of writing instruction in school, students should have mastered the art of writing before coming to college. It involves reading and analysis as much as it does writing and editing. Students can help by communicating continually with their professors; by asking the professors to help establish a time schedule both for submitting work and receiving commentary; by arriving at a clear understanding about the scope, emphasis, and length of the dissertation; by showing a preliminary draft of each chapter; by working at the campus or designated research facility; and by striving to attain a realistic balance between efficiency and perfection. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. But if we keep expecting students who can’t construct decent sentences to magically produce coherent essays, we’ll remain a nation of lousy writers forever. Natalie Wexler: If students can’t they write, how can they learn? Still, if you can’t write a sentence, you can’t write, and too many of today’s students just can’t write sentences. Therefore, students rarely experience any significant penalties for their bad behaviors in writing. Then there is that increasing problem of students who take someone else’s car for a joy ride. These requirements may include substantially revising the paper, attending a writing workshop, taking a writing proficiency examination, or registering for a developmental writing course. And while the Common Core demands that students engage in critical thinking, sentence-length assignments can fulfill that mandate as well as longer ones. Once they can write paragraphs, they can tackle essays. They may get a low mark on an assignment, but it would a rare event indeed if a student failed a course for an inadequate writing performance. Once they can write paragraphs, they can tackle essays. As you might imagine, this change has fostered quite a bit of anxiety (and in some cases, outright outrage) on the part of a few colleagues who believe that if we drop a course in writing, we have dodged our duty to ensure that all students can write clearly and correctly. You have to learn to add before you can do calculus. Just imagine the line at the dean’s door! Surely one reason so many Americans lack writing skills is that, for decades, most U.S. schools haven’t taught them. I have also had students with little interest in writing because they have had no personally satisfying experiences in writing in high school. Over the past two and a half years, we have examined programs at similar colleges and studied best practices nationwide. At my university, I chair a faculty committee charged with reviewing and revising our general education curriculum. All faculty members are hereby authorized to challenge their students’ writing proficiency. Then there are those students who fail to give themselves enough time to handle the complex process of planning, drafting, revising, and editing their work. Faced with high school seniors who can’t compose a simple sentence, teachers may throw up their hands when confronted with an English language arts standard saying their students should “use appropriate and varied transitions and syntax to link the major sections of the text, create cohesion, and clarify the relationships among complex ideas and concepts.”. Students who fail to demonstrate the generally accepted minimum standards of proficiency in writing may be issued a “writing ticket” by their instructors. There’s value to that kind of exercise, but it doesn’t provide kids with the tools they need to write analytically. It’s no secret that many Americans are lousy writers. We would have to institute placement and assessment procedures to ensure that students receive effective introductory instruction and can demonstrate proficiency in writing at an appropriate level before moving forward. And few teachers have been trained to teach these writing skills, apparently because educators believe that students will just pick them up through reading. This leads me to my modest proposal. Many graduate without that fundamental skill. Graduate students are also plagued by their multiple roles and ambiguous situations, the mixture of dependence and independence, and freedom and responsiblity--all of which create tensions and problems particular to their writing. First, let me draw a quick analogy between driving and writing. At her school, 100 percent of students come from low-income families. Similarly, before students can write a coherent five-paragraph essay, they need to learn to write a decent sentence — no matter what grade they’re in. The Common Core’s failure to acknowledge that many older students lack basic writing skills can have counterproductive results. That gives the teacher a manageable opportunity not only to correct writing mistakes, but also to uncover what students haven’t understood. An author apologizes for an Inside Higher Ed article he recently wrote (opinion), Trump's claim about saving HBCUs was false, but his administration has largely backed sector, Trump administration proposes major overhaul to student visa rules, New CDC guidance gives colleges more information on COVID-19 testing, but public health experts stil, Concrete steps faculty and administrators can take this fall to challenge systemic racism (opinion), How to write an effective diversity statement (essay), 10 strategies to support students and help them learn during the coronavirus crisis (opinion), Higher Education Events Calendar & People, Students in great need of mental health support during pandemic, We are retiring comments and introducing Letters to the Editor. In 2011, a nationwide test found that only 24 percent of students in eighth and 12th grades were proficient in writing, and just 3 percent were advanced. Just ask any college professor or employer, including those at prestigious institutions. In your essay, write about professors in the programs whose work interests you and why. They claim that their students don’t know how to write as it is, and our proposal will only make matters worse. Most drivers are good drivers because the rules of the road are public and shared, they are consistently enforced, and the consequences of bad driving are clear. And we would have to issue tickets. It’s understandable that educators and policymakers feel a sense of urgency about getting students to write at length in the upper grades. What would the consequences of such a policy be? We would also have to join with our colleagues in academic support services to recruit, hire, and train effective tutors. Natalie Wexler chairs the board of trustees for the Writing Revolution. A major cause of writing anxiety among graduate students is their previous academic success. Keep supporting great journalism by turning off your ad blocker. We would be required to develop more consistent ways of assigning, responding to, and evaluating writing. The least they can get away with or the later they can turn it in, the better. University-level scholarship should be where they refine their rhetorical skills while exploring courses of study. Why Graduate Students Can't Write: Implications of Research on Writing Anxiety for Graduate Education. Be the first to know.Get our free daily newsletter. Writing tickets become part of students’ institutional “writing records.” Students may have tickets removed from their writing records by completing requirements identified by their instructors. That doesn’t mean teachers should drill students on grammar rules, an approach that research has shown doesn’t actually work. But not so many after awhile when students soon learn the consequences of going too fast, too slow, or in the wrong direction, stopping in the wrong place or failing to stop altogether, forgetting to signal when making a turn, or just ending up in a wreck. Students who fail to have tickets removed from their records will receive additional penalties, such as a failing grade for the course, academic probation, or the inability to register for classes. A major cause of writing anxiety among graduate students is their previous academic success. Professors would also be required to get together, talk seriously and openly, and come to agreements about what they think are “generally accepted minimum standards of proficiency in writing” at various levels, in each discipline, and across the board. Worse, their attempts to do so show that many can't follow a logical train of thought or present a reasoned argument. In response, we have begun to propose a new curriculum that responds to some of the weaknesses in our current program (few shared courses and little curricular oversight), and adds what we believe will be some new strengths (first-year seminars and a junior-level multidisciplinary seminar). Most college professors would prefer to complain about poor writing than simply refuse to accept it. During this time, I have had many students who demonstrate passive aggressive behavior when it comes to completing writing projects. Bloom, Lynn Z. And learning to write clearly requires learning to think clearly. I believe most faculty think that when they find an error in grammar or logic or format, it is because their students don’t know “how” to write. When students have a basic grasp of sentences, then — and only then — should they move on to planning and drafting paragraphs. And I believe that the first and last are the most frequent causes of error. Obviously, most don’t. A few years ago I argued in this Pope Center article for a new kind of college writing course where the central point is … Many have graduate degrees. During your graduate studies, you’ll likely do research, and graduate programs want to know that you can both participate in ongoing research as well as find a mentor for your own project. I believe most students would become better writers if the rules of writing were public and shared, they were consistently enforced, and the consequences of bad writing were made clear. But that’s often not the case, especially in high-poverty environments. But the authors of the Common Core focused just on the skills that students should have at each grade level, not on how to impart them. If students get writing assignments at all, they’re usually of the “write about how you feel” variety. I have been teaching first-year writing for many years, and I have directed rhetoric and compositions programs at two universities. First of all, it would mean that we would have to take writing-across-the curriculum more seriously than most of us do now. Still, I sympathize with my colleagues who are frustrated with the quality of writing they encounter. When I find significant errors in student writing, I chalk it up to one of three reasons: they don’t care, they don’t know, or they didn’t see it. Generally, students need to learn how people write as opposed to how they speak.