06 Dec 2017 — expanded Kanye example, Pingback: Wednesday, November 6th–Senior Comp « Stearns, Pingback: Links for exercises on using sources |, still confused on how to insert things when needed and basically using it in general paper is due wednesday rough draft. I was (and still am) under a ton of deadlines, so I wasn’t able to stop back here right away…, FYI: The Banzhaf essay in question is in a textbook called: Simply finding two credible sources that disagree with each other, and taking one side or the other, is often good enough. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. In a similar way, if your paper mainly cites poets, you might need to identify somebody else as an editor or literary critic. Discovering the mis-cited, mis-cited information in the Banzhaf essay/NYT article led me to my thesis topic for paper #2. It’s far more likely that they may simply live in perpetual fear of silence. giggle…) And it is difficult, if not impossible, to write effectively about a text that you have not understood. It would be impossible to make this complex argument in a paper composed of separate paragraphs that engage with one source at a time. Excellent, sir. ISBN-13: 978-0393931747, The final was due within hours of my last post, so I had to make a corporate decision as to what(whom) I should cite…I picked Banzhaf. In high school, you may have been rewarded for introducing every quote with a full sentence identifying the author and mentioning the author’s credentials. Consider instead the following, more intellectually complex use of sources: Point 1 (If A is right that all novels are fiction, and B is right that In Cold Blood is nonfiction, then what do we make of C’s claim that In Cold Blood is a novel? The following examples show three different ways that the same quoted material could be used to advance an original argument, by directly tying the material from one source to related material from another source. “They Say/I Say”: The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing : With Readings. This revision is perhaps a bit hard to follow, when taken out of context. So I Google An Economic Analysis of Obesity and find it’s REALLY: An Economic Analysis of Adult Obesity: Results from the Behavioral In addition, “In the book… it talks” is ungrammatical (“the book” and “it” are redundant subjects) and nonsensical (books don’t talk). We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Quotations must be identical to the original, using a narrow segment of the source. Before the invention of the typewriter, “an omnipresent metaphor” among professional writers concerned “a very male stylus” writing upon the passive, feminized “white sheet of nature or virginity” (Kittler 186). New York: W.W. Norton &, 2009. INTEGRATING SOURCES INTO YOUR PAPER Sunderman/1A In previous writing assignments, many of you have attempted (sometimes successfully, sometimes not) to incorporate ideas from other sources into your papers. When I read my professor’s critiques of my paper, however, she was deadly accurate as to what I needed to improve upon. Don’t expend words writing about quotes and sources. 1999), The Emissary (ST:TNG Rewatch: Season Two, Episode 20) — Enjoyable Worf-centered Romance, One engineer who figures prominently in all accounts of the 1986 Challenger accident says NASA was “absolutely relentless and Machiavellian” (, This passage integrates a very brief quotation (just four words) into a sentence that helps the author make a point. The mis-cited, mis-cited :) statement is on page 28: “Without trend terms, the increase in the per capita number of restaurants makes the Course Evaluation Tasks; Integrating sources into your writing. Again, rather than just asking the question, you would take a position, and present the evidence that supports your position. ENG 101—Composition I Parkland College Instructor: Dr. Thomas Barnard Integrating Sources into Your Own Writing One of the criteria for successful source-based papers is as follows: "Successful and clear integration of source material” (quotes/paraphrases from other writers). Conclusion: “Therefore, this paper has shown that A, B, and C all relate to topic X.”. When you sort through your notes, deciding which specific notes you'll use and how you'll use them once you … Avoid a rigid, simplistic organizational structure focused only on summarizing or reflecting on the sources you have found. largest contribution to trends in weight outcomes, accounting for 69 percent of the growth in In the book Why I Love Words by humorist Ira Talott, we see a similar point is made on page 45. At any rate, that’s enough of a warning sign that I’d say the problem is not how to cite Banzhaf, but rather how to trace the 68% statistic directly to its source. Talott is sympathetic towards “compulsive communicators,” who are “boring at parties” (45), but who are not actually arrogant. I’m thinking it should be: NBER Working Paper No. If you provide a lengthy introduction such as “In the book My Big Boring Academic Study, by Professor H. Pompous Windbag III, it says” or “the following quote by a government study shows that…” you are wasting words that would be better spent developing your ideas. – for even taking the time to fact-check the quote… 9247 ______________________________________. By contrast, the word “typewriter” referred to the machine as well as the female typist who used it (183). How good is a composer who only lets one instrument play at a time? Conclusion: Based on how you resolved the problems you noted above, what new insights are available? Keep up the awesome work on helping all of us of out here in “the intertoobs” land… we, the unwashed masses of inept paper writers :) Shin-Yi Chou, Michael Grossman and Henry Saffer Most professional researchers will put this level of scrutiny into every source they plan to use in their papers, which is why it’s worth the effort for students to find and use peer-reviewed academic sources, rather than random web pages. This revision is marginally better, but only because it uses fewer words — it’s still not integrating the outside quote into the author’s own argument. When you sat down to take notes from your sources, you made some preliminary decisions on whether you would quote, paraphrase or summarize that material. Jerz > Writing > Academic > [ Argument | Titles | Thesis Statements | Blueprinting | Quoting | Citing | MLA Format ]. If I quote Chou’s paper, I’m thinking that is considered an “outside source”? October 2002 (I’m still trying to work out how I’m going to explain somewhere in that paper that ya’ got ta’ put da’ lime in de’ coconut… but it’ll come to me…). Pure excellence. Don’t give the full, high-schoolish introduction without a good reason — the presence of irrelevant details is a signal to your reader that you don’t know what you want to say. If you are taking your learning this seriously, I don’t see how you can go wrong. These are subtleties that you cannot really investigate when you introduce outside sources only in self-contained paragraphs that reference no other sources. Citing him was easier than going with the MBER paper :), I received a solid “B”. They are compulsive communicators. If you bring your essay to a screeching halt in order to introduce the full name and credentials of each author, you will bury whatever argument you were trying to make. The reason I ask is… I learned from you, elsewhere on your site, that I should not quote from an “outside source”… These people are, This quote shows that people who talk too much may not actually be able to help themselves, so we should, Integrated Quotes: Citing Sources Effectively in MLA-Style Papers. By Gerald Graff, Cathy Birkenstein, and Russel K. Durst. Have you ever noticed how some people just won’t shut up? Even if you don't know what you want to write your paper about, you need to be asking yourself the same questions as … (I’ve included my own lead-in, for your to see what I’m trying to quote), …it is one of these footnotes that refers us to a study done by the National Bureau of Economic Statistics and subsequently reported in the New York Times that the “growth of fast-food accounted for 68 percent of the rise in American obesity”. Your own detective work was pretty good, too! He or she is doing twice or three times the work it would take just to give you a single grade, and you will learn a lot if you take full advantage of the opportunity. JEL No. The streets are full of people who talk to themselves, who write journal entries to nobody. In the book Why I Love Words by humorist Ira, The streets are full of people who talk to themselves, who write journal entries to nobody. These people are boring at parties, but are they arrogant? Instead of just asking the question, you would take a position and write a paragraph that presents evidence to defend that position.). Do they feel that speaking and writing is more important than listening and reading? I don’t know anything about economics, so I don’t know whether perhaps the same organization had a recent name change, but it looks to me like Google references to NBES are actually talking about the NBER instead. He uses footnotes to provide references to validate his statements. 03 Oct 2007 — extracted and expanded from a handout that focused on finding good sources. (If you can’t supply at least as many words of your own analysis of and rebuttal to the quoted passage, then you are probably padding.) MLA’s website doesn’t provide specific formatting help (buy the book :) For example, in a paper on the history of the typewriter, you might want to refer to the typist who appears in T. S. Eliot’s poem, “The Waste Land.” If so, you should identify the source as a poem, so that reader won’t mistake the reference for an academic article. (I’d start by looking for the NYT article that Banzhaf mentions. If you must use the original author’s language, work a few words from the outside source into a sentence you wrote yourself. I’m quoting an author named John Banzhaf and have a question about how to cite the quote. In fact, reading and writing work best when one process fuels or informs the other. You summarized, paraphrased, or quoted ideas from our readings to help develop your … I’m in a college English Comp class and am working on a thesis paper. If you want to use that statistic, I wouldn’t cite Banzhaf at all — which looked like a random website, not a scholarly publication. In one of his footnotes, he quotes an excerpt from an article in the New York Times. Write a Short Story Have you ever noticed how some people just won’t shut up? The passages “it talks about” and “As you can see from this quote” are very weak attempts to engage with the ideas presented by Kittler. In the mid 1880s, “an omnipresent metaphor equated women with the white sheet of nature or virginity onto which a very male stylus could inscribe the glory of its authorship” (Kittler 186), but all this would change when women started working as professional typists. Active and Passive Verbs 20 Dec 2016 — further reorganization and updates They must match the source document word for word and must be attributed to the original author. You blow my doors off with your attention to detail. I constructed this three-way argument in order to demonstrate a complex order that does not focus on one source at a time. I’ll ask her permission to scan in and send to you…might be something cool to pass along. Rather than just asking the question, here is where you would present your answer, and write a paragraph that draws on all 3 sources to support the position you take. You rock! But businesses were soon clamoring for the services of typists, who were mostly female. (Banzhaf 166), I asked my professor, and she wasn’t sure. According to Kittler, the concept of the pen as a masculine symbol imposing form and order upon feminized, virginal paper was “an omnipresent metaphor” (186) in the days before the typewriter. Integrating Sources into Your Writing | Guidelines | Quoting | Paraphrasing | Summarizing | Using Too Much Source Material.